Learn

The Christmas tree is rarely the problem

Most dogs barely notice the tree. The ones who fall apart in December are usually reacting to everything that moves around it, which is a different problem with different fixes. Plus the hazards that are real, in proportion.

By Kirsten Pohle · · 8 min read

Every December somebody writes that you should watch your dog around the tree, and every December a lot of people read it, look at their dog ignoring the tree completely, and move on.

They are right to. Most dogs find a tree mildly interesting for an afternoon and then treat it as furniture. If yours is one of them, the only part of this that matters to you is the short list of things that are genuinely dangerous, and you can skip to it.

But some dogs do come apart in December, and when they do, the tree takes the blame because the tree is the thing that appeared. It is usually not the tree. It is everything that happened in order to get the tree there.

What actually changed

Stand in your living room on December the first and then again on December the fifth, and count the differences.

The furniture moved. A chair that has been in the same place for two years is now somewhere else, which means the route from the sofa to the water bowl is different, and so is the angle from the dog bed to the front door. Boxes came out of a closet that is normally shut, carrying the smell of a closet that is normally shut. There are new objects at nose height. Something in the corner smells like outdoors but is indoors, which is a category error if you are a dog.

The light changed. Things in the room now flash, or glow, or move when the heating comes on.

And the people changed. Somebody is up a ladder. Somebody is carrying something awkward and walking differently because of it. Voices are raised across rooms. Music that is not normally on is on. Over the following three weeks the doorbell will ring more than it has all year, and a proportion of those arrivals will be people your dog has met once.

For a dog who copes fine with change, none of that registers as anything. For a dog who does not, it is a month of small surprises in the one place that is supposed to be predictable. That is the actual stressor, and the tree is just the most visible part of it.

This matters because it changes what you do. If you think the tree is frightening your dog, you work on the tree. If you understand that the house has stopped being predictable, you work on the predictability, which is both easier and more likely to help.

What to do about it

Put it up in stages. The single most useful change costs nothing. Bring the boxes in one evening and leave them. Put the bare tree up the next evening and leave it. Decorate the evening after. A dog who finds change hard is not objecting to the final state of the room, they are objecting to a room that reorganized itself in ninety minutes while they were trying to sleep in it. Three small changes are much easier to absorb than one large one.

Keep one thing exactly the same. Whatever your dog's spot is, do not move it, do not put a box on it, and do not make it the place where the tree skirt lives. If everything in the room is going to change, their one piece of it should not. The same goes for the clock: walks and meals at the usual times do more for a nervous dog in December than anything else on this list.

Let them investigate when the house is calm. Not while you are decorating, not while anyone is on a ladder. Afterwards, when it is quiet, let them go and sniff the thing properly without anybody watching and commenting. A dog who has been allowed to examine something thoroughly at their own pace generally stops caring about it. A dog who has been told to leave it alone every time they approach has learned that it is important without learning that it is harmless.

Watch the early signs rather than the obvious ones. A dog who is finding the month hard will usually tell you long before they bark at a bauble. Not settling in the evening. Getting up and relocating repeatedly. Choosing a different room from the one the family is in. Eating more slowly or less. Those are the ones worth logging, because by the time it looks like a reaction, you have missed a week of information.

The guests are a separate problem. The hardest part of December for most reactive dogs is not the decorations, it is the number of people coming through the door. That has its own answers, and they are in Guests when your dog is reactive.

The hazards that are real

Now the short list. These apply to every dog, calm or not, and some of them are badly misreported, so here they are in proportion.

The water in the stand is the one to take seriously, and almost nobody does. It is more dangerous than the needles. Standing water around a cut trunk grows bacteria and mold, and if you have used a preservative or a fertilizer, that is in there too. The AKC Canine Health Foundation puts it plainly: only a few sips may make a pet extremely sick. Cover the stand. A tree skirt is not a cover, because a determined dog goes under it. Use something solid.

Tinsel, ribbon and anything long and thin belongs out of reach, and this is the one that ends in surgery. A long thin object is not the same kind of problem as a swallowed bauble. One end lodges, often at the base of the tongue or in the stomach, while the rest keeps being pulled along by the intestine. The gut bunches up around it and the object can saw through the intestinal wall. The Merck Veterinary Manual treats this as an emergency, notes it usually needs exploratory surgery rather than endoscopy, and adds one instruction worth knowing in advance: if you can see string anchored under the tongue, do not pull it. Pulling can perforate the bowel. Get to a vet.

The same applies to ribbon from presents, the hanging loops on ornaments, and the string on a gift tag.

Salt dough ornaments are the hazard nobody warns you about. If there are children in the house, there is a reasonable chance somebody will make them. The recipe is mostly salt, dogs like them, and they have killed dogs. Signs of salt toxicosis run from vomiting, diarrhea, lethargy and excessive thirst through to incoordination, tremors and seizures. If your dog eats one, that is a phone call now, not in the morning. Hang them somewhere a dog cannot reach, or do not make them.

Mistletoe is the plant to worry about. Poinsettia mostly is not. Poinsettia's reputation is out of all proportion to its toxicity: the sap can irritate the mouth and cause vomiting, and that is generally the extent of it. Holly is worse than that but still mostly a stomach problem, with reduced appetite, vomiting, diarrhea and lethargy. Mistletoe is the serious one, and ingesting the berries or leaves can cause severe gastrointestinal signs along with cardiovascular effects such as low blood pressure and a slowed heart rate, and neurological signs including collapse.

Pine needles cause stomach upset and lethargy, and the mechanism is not actually known. Not usually an emergency, worth sweeping up anyway, and worth mentioning to your vet if your dog has been unwell and you have a tree.

Lights, cords and the things on the low branches. A chewed cord is a burned mouth at best. Run cords where they cannot be reached or where they are taped down, and keep the breakable and the edible ornaments above dog height. Chocolate decorations are chocolate, and the dose that matters depends on the kind and your dog's size: that is covered in what your dog can and cannot eat.

If something gets eaten

Do not wait to see how it goes, and do not make your dog vomit unless somebody qualified has told you to on this occasion. For some of what is on this page that makes things worse.

Call your vet. If it is out of hours, the ASPCA Animal Poison Control Center is on (888) 426-4435 and the Pet Poison Helpline is on (855) 764-7661, both around the clock, both charging a fee that is considerably less than the alternative.

Take the packaging, the label, or what is left of the object with you. "Some kind of ornament" is a much worse starting point for a vet than a torn box with an ingredient list on it.

The short version

The tree is rarely the thing frightening your dog. The month around the tree might be, and that is worth noticing early rather than at the point where somebody is shouting at a dog for barking at a visitor.

Put it up slowly, leave their spot alone, keep the clock the same, and cover the water.

Get the next one

New guides as they go up, and nothing in between.

Anything else? All optional.

We check out trainers, vets and boarding one area at a time, and this is how we know which areas people are actually waiting in. Giving it means we go looking near you rather than in whichever city we happen to know best. Five digits, never a street address.

Your email address, your ZIP code if you give it, and which guide you signed up from. That is everything we ask for and everything we keep. We do not sell or share any of it, your ZIP never leaves us and is only ever counted alongside everyone else’s, and every message has an unsubscribe link that takes one click.