Learn

What to ask a trainer before you book

Anyone can call themselves a dog trainer. Seven questions that tell you what you are actually hiring, and what the answers should sound like.

Other Dogs and AnimalsHandling SensitivityFear-Based / NoiseBy Kirsten Pohle · · 5 min read

Several trainers took us on and then quit. Not because our dog was dangerous, but because they did not know how to work with an anxious one. Each time cost us a few months and a fair amount of hope.

These are the questions I wish I had known to ask first, and what the answers should sound like.

A woman at a kitchen table writing a list of questions in a notebook, her black dog lying on the rug beside her.

Is dog training regulated in the United States?

It is not. There is no license, no required education, and no governing body with the power to stop anyone calling themselves a behaviorist. The certifications that exist are all voluntary.

Which puts the checking on you, and makes the questions below worth the small awkwardness of asking them.

1. What certifications do you hold?

You are listening for a specific abbreviation, not a reassuring sentence.

The ones that involve a proctored exam and continuing education include CPDT-KA (Certified Professional Dog Trainer, Knowledge Assessed), CBCC-KA (Certified Behavior Consultant Canine, Knowledge Assessed), KPA CTP (Karen Pryor Academy Certified Training Partner), and CDBC through the IAABC. Fear Free certification covers low-stress handling specifically.

For reactivity in particular, CBCC-KA and CDBC are the two that point to behavior work rather than general obedience.

"Certified" on its own is not an answer. Ask which body, then look the person up on that body's own register. The certifying organizations publish searchable lists and it takes about a minute.

2. What happens when my dog gets it wrong?

This is the question that matters most, and the one worth listening to hardest.

You are listening for what the consequence is for a mistake. Answers built around redirecting, lowering the difficulty, adding distance or ending the session describe one approach. Answers built around corrections, leash pops, a prong or an e-collar, or "showing him it is not acceptable" describe another.

Be wary of language that sounds gentle but is not specific: "balanced", "we use all four quadrants", "pressure and release", "we communicate in a way the dog understands". Ask what the tool is and what it physically does.

One thing worth keeping in mind is that a straight answer is a good sign regardless of which approach it describes. The ones to be careful of are not the people who told you plainly what they do. They are the people who would not say.

3. Have you worked with a dog like mine?

Not "do you work with reactivity", which everyone says yes to. Ask for a case: a dog with a similar trigger, what the plan was, and roughly how long it took.

Someone who has done it will describe a process with stages. Someone who has not will describe a result.

If they cannot think of an example, that is not disqualifying on its own. It should move them down the list rather than off it.

4. What does success look like at six weeks?

A trainer who promises your dog will be fine around other dogs in six weeks is selling something.

Reactivity work is usually measured in threshold distance and recovery time, not in the behavior disappearing. A good answer sounds like: your dog notices another dog at forty feet instead of eighty, and settles in thirty seconds instead of five minutes.

That is a real change, and more to the point it is one you can check yourself.

A woman comparing trainers on a laptop at her desk while her black dog sits and waits next to the chair.

5. Are you insured?

This is a yes or a no, and the answer should come straight back. Professional liability insurance is standard for anyone operating seriously.

A pause here tells you something on its own.

6. Can I watch a session before I commit?

Many trainers offer this, and the ones who do not should have a reason that makes sense when you hear it.

Ten minutes of watching someone work tells you more than an hour of talking to them.

7. What if the right trainer is not near me?

This one took me far too long to work out.

The trainer who finally helped us was nowhere near where we lived, and we met over video. For reactivity that works better than you would expect, because much of the work is you learning to read your dog and to change the environment around them, and both of those can be taught remotely.

Some things do need hands on the leash. But if the only qualified person for your dog's particular problem is three states away, a video consultation with the right person beats an in-person hour with the wrong one.

What should I bring to a first session?

If you have been tracking, bring the log. A trainer handed "he is reactive to dogs" is starting from scratch. A trainer handed fourteen days of entries with distances, intensities and what helped is starting from data, and will usually say so.

If there is any bite history, including guarding that has involved teeth, say so plainly and early. It changes the plan, the safety setup and sometimes who the right professional is, and it is not something anyone should be discovering in week three.

Do certifications guarantee a good trainer?

They do not, and it is worth saying plainly.

None of these questions guarantees a good outcome. What they tell you is whether the person in front of you has done the work, which is the most you can establish before you start.

Some excellent trainers hold none of these credentials and some poor ones hold several. Treat them as a floor rather than a ceiling, and treat question two as the one that really sorts people.

Get the next one

New guides as they go up, and nothing in between.

Anything else? All optional.

We check out trainers, vets and boarding one area at a time, and this is how we know which areas people are actually waiting in. Giving it means we go looking near you rather than in whichever city we happen to know best. Five digits, never a street address.

Your email address, your ZIP code if you give it, and which guide you signed up from. That is everything we ask for and everything we keep. We do not sell or share any of it, your ZIP never leaves us and is only ever counted alongside everyone else’s, and every message has an unsubscribe link that takes one click.